Ofgem’s data centre connection fee: risks for UK developers

By
Kenneth Addly

Share this:

Ofgem has consulted on proposals that data centre projects at or above 40 MW connection capacity must secure a ‘returnable’ data centre commitment fee (DCCF) of £237,500 to £712,500 per MW (exact figure to be determined). This is equivalent to 2.5% to 7.5% of benchmark capex of 9.5 million per MW. The DCCF would be secured on acceptance of a connection offer and returned only at energisation. The outcome of the consultation is now awaited.

The implications of the DCCF

The policy objective is understandable. Connection queues have become congested by projects that may never proceed, while viable developments wait for access to capacity. Few would dispute the need for reform. The real question is whether the DCCF can distinguish between speculative projects and schemes that are deliverable but face genuine development constraints relating to planning, financing, land assembly or timing.

Creating the DCCF – a financial instrument – as a queue reduction lever solely aimed at data centre developers, is likely to have significant market structuring consequences in the data centre development space:

·       Developers may need to commit to higher financing costs and earlier capital commitment. This is likely to favour developers with strong balance sheets e.g. hyper-scalers.

·       Independent developers (particularly ‘powered land’ developers)  may need to bring in investors or sell projects at an earlier stage.

·       The market is likely to equate financial viability as a proxy for project viability.

·       Depending on the economics, the DCCF could encourage private wire solutions for energy demand. For example, a 39 MW grid connection plus 20 MW private wire connected to an on site generator would appear to fall outside of the DCCF obligations.

The consultation contains no planning-refusal exemption. A developer posts the DCCF while planning risk is still live and carries that exposure through the consenting period. Under current arrangements the downside of a failed planning application is broadly the sunk development expenditure and any securities exposure under the NESO final sums methodology. Under Ofgem’s DCCF proposals, the DCCF would sit on top. Planning risk therefore converts from a development cost risk into a sizeable balance sheet risk.

Will the DCCF help create an unfavourable investment environment?

The DCCF would impose a substantially greater upfront security requirement than international examples identified by Ofgem. Its competitiveness impact will, though, depend on the duration and forfeiture conditions of that exposure, and whether it produces a commensurate improvement in connection certainty and delivery.

The answer may also depend on the developer’s market positioning. For a hyperscaler, the effects may be less significant. For an independent developer the effects may be more profound, and capital may be re-deployed into other sectors. The quantum of the DCCF may be less of an issue than the pressing need to create a settled regulatory environment. Reform was inevitable but developers and funders need to be able to chart a course across calmer waters.  

Regulatory models that allow for significant post investment adjustments that can adversely  impact on cost of capital are sub-optimal. For example, the Ofgem proposals discuss adjusting the DCCF value and the 40 MW threshold over time for developers who have already committed to the DCCF. The detail post consultation will be important.

Beyond developers’ concerns a valid question is whether the DCCF will have an adverse impact on UK government wider industrial policy. If connection delivery remains slow while substantial security is tied up, the DCCF risks becoming an obstacle to date centre/industrial policy. This question becomes more acute in light of the government’s newly announced British Data Centre Covenant, which seeks to accelerate strategic data centre delivery by offering qualifying projects improved access to grid connections in return for commitments to local investment, job creation and environmental stewardship.

The effectiveness of the DCCF will therefore need to be assessed not only as a queue management tool, but also against the government’s wider objective of rapidly expanding UK digital infrastructure.

Kenneth Addly, Of Counsel, London, at BCLP

LEGAL & PROFESSIONAL

Do you have a legal & professional story you want to share with your built environment colleagues and peers? Do you have a comment piece you are keen to write? Is there a legal & professional story you think we should be covering? 

REGISTER TODAY

to get our daily newsletter, with all the latest news, views and analysis, delivered straight to your inbox – for FREE!

BE CONNECTED

We offer a wide variety of business-critical content and networking services to suit every budget